SYMPHONIE
Nr.10, Op.93
Berliner Philharmoniker
Dir: Herbert von Karajan.
(DG)
*
Hoy hace 50 años, 9 de agosto de 1975, fallecía en Moscú Dimitri Shostakovich, probablemente el último gran compositor sinfonista en la gran tradición inaugurada por Haydn, y permanente piedra en el zapato del brutal régimen comunista de la entonces Unión Soviética.
*
Su muerte no fue anunciada por Pravda hasta tres días después, aunque se le dieron funerales ¨de estado¨ entre el 14 y 15 de agosto. Sin embargo la noticia se difundió casi inmediatamente en Occidente. Es célebre el momento de aquel 9 de agosto en que en medio del concierto de Tanglewood donde Rostropovich dirigía la 5ta sinfonía, se leyó en el intermedio el telegrama dirigido a Ozawa con la noticia y Rostropovich elevando la partitura y con lágrimas en los ojos la besó.
*
Aunque el tema es discutible, muchos consideran a la Sinfonía Nr.10 como su mejor obra sinfónica. La Décima arriba después de un largo silencio sinfónico. Fue iniciada por Shostakovich en
julio de 1953 y terminada en octubre de ese mismo año, aunque varios de sus materiales ya estaban hace rato en las gavetas del compositor. La Premiére estuvo a
cargo de Evgeni Mravinsky, quien la dirigió en Leningrado (actual San Petersburgo)
el 17 de diciembre de 1953.
*
El 5 de marzo de 1953 moría Stalin, después de tres
décadas de terror y de brutal opresión. Shostakovich se había mantenido en bajo
perfil después del disgusto ocasionado al dictador por el episodio de la 9na
Sinfonía y de la condena oficial de ésta obra así como de la Sinfonía Nr. 8. Con la muerte de Stalin y
Zhdanov se dió paso a un ligero ambiente de distensión en todos los ámbitos de
la sociedad soviética, y el mundo de las artes no escapaba a éste definitivo
cambio de era. Ya Shostakovich era un valor nacional demasiado importante para
poder tocarlo sin consecuencias, y de este modo ya no sentía tanta presión de
transigir en cuanto a su lenguaje musical. Con coraje permitió que se presentara
entonces la 10ma, una obra encriptada como las anteriores y totalmente alejada del optimismo y del
"realismo socialista".
*
Las reacciones fueron igual de encontradas que en los casos de sus dos antecesoras. La obra encontró oposición. Fue criticada
por su complejidad, sus texturas lúgubres y sus tendencias nihilistas. El
sindicato de compositores soviéticos se sumergió en la bizantina discusión
sobre si la obra era suficientemente optimista, llegándose a una solución
rocambolescamente insólita, al catalogarla como expresión de "optimismo
pesimista". Como suele ocurrir en el socialismo, se injerta un significado
políticamente conveniente a una expresión artística que no entienden.
*
A continuación anexo las siempre valiosísimas notas de Mark Wigglesworth, en éste caso referente a la obra que nos ocupa:
Symphony
No. 10 in E minor, Op.93
The
first movement, a huge arching slow waltz that builds to a climax as inevitably
as it recedes away from it is an amazing journey that, despite apparently
ending where it began, has travelled an enormous distance. Structurally it is
the most perfect single orchestral movement he ever wrote. Emotionally there is
a tired and drained quality that reflects Akhmatova’s line: ‘How sad that there
is no one else to lose, and one can weep.’ We feel the exhaustion of all who
lived through the twenty-five years of Stalin’s tyranny.
It
was a regime whose brutal inexhaustibility Shostakovich portrays in the
breathtaking second movement. It begins fortissimo and is followed by no fewer
than fifty crescendos. There are only two diminuendos. The effect is
self-explanatory. The emotion is not so much a depiction of Stalin himself, but
an anger that he ever existed. In fact, such was his hold over the people, that
the hysteria greeting his funeral cortege was so great that hundreds of people
were crushed to death by tanks trying to keep order and protect the coffin. It
is typical of Stalin that he should have continued to be responsible for people’s
deaths even from beyond the grave.
Like
the first movement, the third is another attempt to dance. This waltz is more
macabre and is based on a theme that is the first four letters of the
composer’s own initial and surname. When the letters DSch are turned into
German musical notation, they spell the notes D-E flat-C-B. But defining his
identity like this does not seem to get him anywhere. The music keeps falling
back on itself. There seems no way out until the cellos and basses, in a
desperate crescendo, stumble as if by chance upon an an initially enigmatic
horn call. This five-note theme appears no less than twelve times – every time
almost identical – and bears a striking resemblance to the opening horn fanfare
of Mahler’s Das Lied von der Erde. The message of this deeply optimistic work
would have undoubtedly struck a chord with Shostakovich. Despite all the
horrors, life itself is beautiful and will always be so despite man’s attempts
to ruin it. The world will always renew itself. Another possible meaning for
the theme is that, using the French system of notation as well as the German
one, the horn call can be taken to spell the name ELMIRA: E-L(a)-Mi-R(e)-A.
Elmira Nazirova was an Azeri pianist and composer who had studied with
Shostakovich. He had become infatuated with her and wrote her numerous letters
during the summer of 1953. Maybe both ‘translations’ are relevant. One
represents eternal nature, the other human love. Both are forces for good and
as such, the most powerful weapons against an evil like Stalin’s. The horn call
symbolises an alternative. Unfortunately there seems no way of connecting with
it. The movement recapitulates the DSch waltz and it becomes increasingly
desperate. There is a story that Gogol used to stare constantly into a mirror
and, in mad self-contemplation, repeatedly call out his own name. There is
something of this mania here. Over and over again the DSch motif is repeated,
frantically trying to assert its individuality. At its almost hysterical
climax, the eternal love theme returns, this time on all four horns and
fortissimo. Yes, that is the answer. That is the alternative. But you wonder if
the realization has come too late. The final horn call is a long way away,
beyond our grasp again.
The
finale opens in a Siberian landscape with solitary woodwind voices trying to
communicate with each other across the barren plains. It is the slowest music
of the whole symphony, a timely reminder of the desolation that the prisoners
were actually experiencing. To survive the camps was a miracle. It was not
uncommon for forty men to be kept in a cell built for four. In fact many were
simply shot as their sentence came to an end on the presumption that if they
were still alive they had either worked less than they should have or eaten
more than their share. At home, life goes on and the ensuing Allegro depicts
the humdrum and meaningless existence of people trying to avoid their own
deportation. The symphony is not sure which is worse. At least the prisoners
were allowed to cry. The fast music never really gets going. As Shostakovich
said, ‘it is very hard to run free when you are constantly looking over your
shoulder.’ You can pretend to be playing games but you will always be playing
them in a kind of prison. The poet Osip Mandelstam’s description of the time is
haunting: ‘We were capable of coming to work with a smile on our face after a
night in which our home had been searched or a relative arrested. It was
essential to smile. If you didn’t, it meant that you were afraid or unhappy.
Nobody could afford to admit this.’
The
purges had made virtually everyone an accomplice. It was like a snowball,
gathering up all it touched. As the somewhat gossipy bassoon begins the
finale’s coda, it is joined one by one by almost everybody else. Galloping
alongside is the evil rhythm of the second movement – the return of the snare
drum giving us no option but to realize that Stalin is the one pushing the
snowball down the hill. But the horns and timpani fight back, hammering out the
DSch motif and with it the desire to remain individual. ‘I will not be beaten’,
he is shouting. ‘You will never get me.’ The defiance is remarkable. The fact
that the opposition to it is still there, however, lends credence to the fact
that Shostakovich could have conceived this work before Stalin died. Perhaps he
just realized that after Stalin would simply come somebody else to repress the
people. Either way, there is no sense of relief at the end of this work, just a
triumphant assertion that, despite the continued presence of tyranny, an
individual with a strong enough spirit can survive. ‘Even if they chop my hands
off,’ he said, ‘I will continue to compose music – even if I have to hold the
pen between my teeth’. Only Shostakovich can be so optimistic, pessimistic, and
ultimately realistic in one work without any sense of contradiction. It is what
makes all his symphonies such vital chronicles of the Twentieth Century.
©
Mark Wigglesworth 1998
DISCOGRAFÍA.
*
En cuanto a la discografía de la Décima, como una de las obras más conocidas y populares de Shostakovich, es de entender que cuente con una amplia discografía recomendable, desde las típicas y enérgicas grabaciones de Mravinsky, quien hizo la primera grabación, pasando por otros grandes directores soviéticos, las emblemáticas grabaciones de Dimitri Mitropoulos y de Karel Ancerl, éste último ya publicado en ARPEGIO y llegando hasta nuestros días con grandes registros como el de Semyon Bychkov en Colonia o el de Vasily Petrenko en Liverpool. De entre las grabaciones más memorables del Op. 93 están adicionalmente dos hechas por Herbert von Karajan al frente de la Filarmónica de Berlín y que cuentan con una altísima reputación bien ganada entre la crítica. Sin ser un director asociado a Shostakovich, por alguna razón Karajan tomó a la Décima como un caballito de batalla, dirigiéndola varias veces y dejando dos grabaciones comerciales para el sello Deutsche Grammophon: una de los años 70´s y luego una más reciente con la entonces tecnología digital. Las dos son un portento interpretativo, por supuesto ganando la versión digital el calidad y nitidez sonora. Aún dentro de una amplia gama de grandes registros, ésta es la recomendación más fácil y estandarizada.
*
In Memoriam, Maestro DSCH.
*
M-S.
1 comentario:
https://mega.nz/file/slcWgRRI#Z6rLF8OMOY2_mZJoXKEYudjsmDrV_vEMdaUZP4ssZTw
Publicar un comentario